Room temperature transformation - A175
Room temperature transformation | |
---|---|
Document Type | Article |
Document Identifier | 175 |
Themes | |
Relevant Class |
Equipment |
Tags | |
Factory Cells | |
Prerequisites |
Introduction[edit | edit source]
Room temperature transformation is considered a piece of equipment from a thermal management standpoint. In this case, the room itself becomes the equipment as it is the room that controls the environmental conditions of the system. In that sense, a room, for the purpose of polymerization, effectively acts as a heating system for thermal transformation. The processing temperature is just much lower than other heating systems, such as ovens or autoclaves. The application of heat to the part functions according to the principles of convective heat transfer. Typically, this implies natural convection unless a fan (or other means) is used to forcibly blow air over the part. While the name implies room temperature (i.e ~20°C), in reality room temperature is used to denote any thermal transformation process taking place in ambient air. Therefore, the environmental conditions may fluctuate if no control systems are in place. The best example is curing outdoors. Here the part may be subject to drastic changes in temperature, airflow, UV radiation, and moisture depending on the weather.
Scope[edit | edit source]
The intent of this page is for the user to understand how a room may behave as a piece of equipment for thermal transformation. The page provides general information on room temperature curing. It does not delve into the scientific principles governing room temperature cure materials or the interaction between components in a room temperature setup.
Significance[edit | edit source]
Room temperature transformation is a low cost, easy-to-implement, and environmentally-friendly way to achieve low temperature thermal transformation of polymers, particularly thermosets. It is common to see room temperature heating setups across a wide range of industries. In fact, room temperature cure of polymers is commonplace in many households with the use of epoxies and other resins for repair operations and art projects. Generally speaking, room temperature heating is reserved for parts where low cost, rather than high-performance is the target.
Prerequisites[edit | edit source]
Recommended documents to review before, or in parallel with this document:
- Thermal transformation
- Heat transfer
- Convection
- Effect of equipment in a thermal management system - see convection section
Overview[edit | edit source]
Room temperature transformation refers to any thermal transformation process occuring at ambient temperature. That is, the temperature of the room in which the part is sitting. Curing of thermoset materials is the most common application of a room temperature transformation. Heat transfer to and from the part occurs via convection with the air. If the part is simply placed in a room and allowed to cure, the part is subject to natural convection of stagnant air. In such a scenario, the heat transfer coefficient (HTC) is usually relatively low, on the order of 2-10 W/m2K[1][2], with extreme cases up to 25 W/m2K[2]. However, if a fan, or other means of forcibly moving air, is used, then the part is subject to forced convection and the HTC is increased. For example, if the part is cured outdoors with wind speeds ranging from just 1 to 4 m/s, the HTC may be in the range of 15-30 W/m2K[3]. These values do depend on temperature, part shape, air density, and consistency of wind speed, however. In general, the greater the wind speed, the higher the HTC.
Vacuum may be applied to the part in a room temperature setup by means of an external vacuum pump. This allows for a pressure application on the part equal to atmospheric pressure, 101 kPa or 14.7 psi at sea level. At higher elevations atmospheric pressure drops and therefore so does the maximum potential pressure that can be applied to the part. It is also possible to increase the pressure by placing the part under a heavy object.
One benefit to room temperature setups, is that any free space can act as the equipment. Therefore, large individual parts or multiple parts may be placed in a given room and allowed to cure simultaneously. This is particularly true for curing outdoors where there is ample space to setup large parts for curing. Minor investments such as a table or other units for raising the parts off the ground are useful in allowing operators to easily move between parts and to reduce moisture ingress, oxidation of the tool, and other environmental impacts from a potentially damp ground in an outdoor setup.
Properties[edit | edit source]
Heating | Temperature | Pressure | Vacuum |
---|---|---|---|
Convective heating - typically natural unless a fan is used or the part is placed outside. HTC is usually 2-10 W/m2K[1][2] for stagnant air. As air velocity increases, the HTC can be upwards of 15 W/m2K[2][3]. | Typical temperature range: 20-25°C if placed indoors in a controlled environment. Outdoor temperatures are dependent on weather. | No pressure control. P\(_{app}\) = 0. | External vacuum control possible. P\(_{vac}\) = -101 kPa (-14.7 psi) at sea level. |
Advantages[edit | edit source]
- Cheap; minimal equipment purchases, low cost tooling (no need for durable tools capable of handling multiple high temperature/pressure cycles)
- Easy to setup
- No energy input required; significant reduction in environmental impact and energy costs.
- Large amount of space for curing large parts or multiple parts - especially if cured outdoors
- Low HTC values if cured in stagnant air conditions; 2-10 W/m2K[1][2]. Unlike for high temperature processing, where a high HTC is desirable, at low ambient air temperatures a low HTC may actually be advantageous (see the following page).
Limitations[edit | edit source]
- Not suitable for high temperature cure materials, such as aerospace-grade carbon epoxies
- Not suitable for melting and crystallization of thermoplastics
- No external pressure application; limited to vacuum pressure
- Generally reduced part quality; low fibre volume fraction, high porosity.
- Highly inconsistent HTC values compared with an oven, if cured outdoors.
- High variability between parts due to fluctuations of environmental conditions, especially in outdoor environments. Part quality is weather dependent.
Use[edit | edit source]
Room temperature transformation is ideal for thermoset materials that don't require high temperatures in order to begin their polymerization reaction. This includes families of resins such as polyesters and vinyl esters. The heat released from the polymerization reaction drives the curing process. This is in contrast to high temperature cure materials such as aerospace-grade carbon epoxies, where the heat released during polymerization may aid in bringing the part to temperature, but first significant heat must be input into the system and then maintained throughout the cycle.
The environmental conditions of the room (or space) in which the part is placed are arguably the most important parameters to consider for a room temperature setup. Ambient air temperature and the HTC have a dramatic affect on the thermal response of room temperature cure materials, and thus play a significant role in influencing their cure reaction. A part cured in a room indoors is likely to be exposed to temperatures on the order of 20-25°C. This may vary, however, if the door to the room is opened frequently, thereby introducing potential changes in temperature. This is especially important if any doors lead to outside the building, where the temperature may be drastically different than indoors. Regarding the HTC, unless a fan or other device is used to blow air over the part, the HTC is likely that of stagnant air. Opening and closing doors may also bring bursts of air currents, thus momentarily altering the HTC over the part. Unlike for high temperature processing, a lower HTC for a room temperature cure may actually be advantageous as the part is effectively insulated allowing the exothermic heat from the part's polymerization reaction to continuing advancing the degree of cure (DOC).
Curing a part outdoors brings even higher variability to the environmental conditions. Now the part is subject to seasonal and daily weather patterns. The ambient air temperature may fluctuate significantly depending on the time of year and the geographical location. This may mean that parts can only be cured in the summer when temperatures are high, or thermal management strategies must implemented for cooler seasons. Similarly, companies with multiple factories may choose to cure all their parts at one location where the local climate is relatively moderate and predictable. Even with such measures, air temperature may change notably from day-to-day or even within the same day. Temperatures at night are generally cooler than during the day, meaning parts cured overnight may reach a lower degree of cure (DOC) than parts cured during the day. In addition, wind will influence the HTC over the part. On days when it is calm, the HTC will be low, on the order of stagnant air. However, if the day is windy, then the HTC will increase drastically. Unlike air temperature, which may remain relatively stable over a season, wind speed can change drastically within a day.
To learn more about how ambient air temperature and the HTC influence the thermal response of room temperature cure setups, visit the following page.
Moisture uptake and UV radiation are other factors to consider for outdoor and, to a lesser extent, indoor curing. Covering the parts with an opaque cover can help mitigate UV degradation. Moisture absorption into the part is more complicated however. If indoors, an air conditioning system can be used to control the humidity. However, for outdoor cures, humidity will be determined by the relative humidity of the air. A possible strategy is to cure the parts in dryer climates, where relative humidity is low. However, dryer climates may also present larger temperature swings, especially between day and night[4][5].
Solidification of liquid thermoplastics may also occur at room temperature. A common example is the use of white glue or carpenter's glue, polyvinyl acetate (PVA). Here, exposure to air allows for water in the liquid glue emulsion to evaporate, thus solidifying the material[6].
Applications[edit | edit source]
Room temperature transformation is fairly common and may be found used for a wide variety of applications including:
- Marine - boat hulls
- Energy infrastructure - wind turbine blades
- Construction and repair - glues and resins for adhesive bonding and filling cracks
- Art - glues and resins for adhesive bonding or filling cracks
- Consumer goods
References
- ↑ 1.0 1.1 1.2 [Ref] Kumar, Suresh; Mullick, S. C. (2010). "Wind heat transfer coefficient in solar collectors in outdoor conditions". 84 (6). Elsevier Ltd. doi:10.1016/j.solener.2010.03.003. ISSN 0038-092X. Cite journal requires
|journal=
(help)CS1 maint: uses authors parameter (link) - ↑ 2.0 2.1 2.2 2.3 2.4 [Ref] Karwa, Rajendra et al. (2020). Heat and Mass Transfer. Springer Singapore. ISBN 9811539871.CS1 maint: extra punctuation (link) CS1 maint: uses authors parameter (link) CS1 maint: date and year (link)
- ↑ 3.0 3.1 [Ref] Kumar, Subodh et al. (1997). "Wind induced heat losses from outer cover of solar collectors". 10 (4). doi:10.1016/S0960-1481(96)00031-6. ISSN 0960-1481. Cite journal requires
|journal=
(help)CS1 maint: extra punctuation (link) CS1 maint: uses authors parameter (link) - ↑ [Ref] NASA Earth Observatory. "Desert". Retrieved 24 February 2021.CS1 maint: uses authors parameter (link)
- ↑ [Ref] Kimble, Chris A.; National Weather Service. "Extreme Temperature Ranges". Retrieved 24 February 2021.CS1 maint: uses authors parameter (link)
- ↑ [Ref] Kaboorani, A.; Riedl, B. (2015). Mechanical performance of polyvinyl acetate (PVA)-based biocomposites. Elsevier Ltd. doi:10.1016/B978-1-78242-373-7.00009-3. ISBN 9781782423942.CS1 maint: uses authors parameter (link) CS1 maint: date and year (link)
About | Help |
Welcome
Welcome to the CKN Knowledge in Practice Centre (KPC). The KPC is a resource for learning and applying scientific knowledge to the practice of composites manufacturing. As you navigate around the KPC, refer back to the information on this right-hand pane as a resource for understanding the intricacies of composites processing and why the KPC is laid out in the way that it is. The following video explains the KPC approach:
Understanding Composites Processing
The Knowledge in Practice Centre (KPC) is centered around a structured method of thinking about composite material manufacturing. From the top down, the heirarchy consists of:
- The factory
- Factory cells and/or the factory layout
- Process steps (embodied in the factory process flow) consisting of:
The way that the material, shape, tooling & consumables and equipment (abbreviated as MSTE) interact with each other during a process step is critical to the outcome of the manufacturing step, and ultimately critical to the quality of the finished part. The interactions between MSTE during a process step can be numerous and complex, but the Knowledge in Practice Centre aims to make you aware of these interactions, understand how one parameter affects another, and understand how to analyze the problem using a systems based approach. Using this approach, the factory can then be developed with a complete understanding and control of all interactions.
Interrelationship of Function, Shape, Material & Process
Design for manufacturing is critical to ensuring the producibility of a part. Trouble arises when it is considered too late or not at all in the design process. Conversely, process design (controlling the interactions between shape, material, tooling & consumables and equipment to achieve a desired outcome) must always consider the shape and material of the part. Ashby has developed and popularized the approach linking design (function) to the choice of material and shape, which influence the process selected and vice versa, as shown below:
Within the Knowledge in Practice Centre the same methodology is applied but the process is more fully defined by also explicitly calling out the equipment and tooling & consumables. Note that in common usage, a process which consists of many steps can be arbitrarily defined by just one step, e.g. "spray-up". Though convenient, this can be misleading.
Workflows
The KPC's Practice and Case Study volumes consist of three types of workflows:
- Development - Analyzing the interactions between MSTE in the process steps to make decisions on processing parameters and understanding how the process steps and factory cells fit within the factory.
- Troubleshooting - Guiding you to possible causes of processing issues affecting either cost, rate or quality and directing you to the most appropriate development workflow to improve the process
- Optimization - An expansion on the development workflows where a larger number of options are considered to achieve the best mixture of cost, rate & quality for your application.